irene taylor brodsky husband

I never, even now, after having made a film about it, I never tired of it. It helps to already be famous to become a social media influencer, but she demonstrates that you need to have a raw or personal touch and engage with your followers if you want to do well on Instagram Facebook, Twiter, Youtube, etc. What he wasn't doing, if you listen to his teacher, who eventually came around, of course, but there's a scene where she says, "Jonas, you're playing it, but you're not playing it well." How did you happen to film that? Moonlight Sonata is effused with love. I look back at all my documentary projects on deaf people, Brodsky says, and I feel as if I didnt know anything. And sort of the perils and excitement that came with that. I want them to be meaningful. But he really went through this transformation in front of our camera quite by accident, and we realized that this film was becoming more and more not just a film about an 11-year-old deaf boy learning how to play a piece written by arguably the most famous deaf person in the world; it was also becoming a story about this deaf boy's grandfather and his own deafness and a story about loss and how we come out on the other side of loss with sometimes something even more gracious. 2100 days ago Collect, curate and comment on your files. Irene Taylor Brodsky is an American filmmaker best known for her documentaries that delve deep into the human experience. They want to make their films more accessible, and that has been something that I have been extremely passionate about and I recently started a nonprofit organization called the Treehouse Project. But it really was a lens into what you hear so many deaf people say all the time, that they don't feel sick. And I can listen to him forever. Pennebaker, Barbara Kopple, and her professor at NYU, George Stoney. Irene's early career began in Kathmandu, Nepal, working as a Himalayan Mountain guide and author. So, I think it's remarkable when you think about a child's resilience, but also his sense of self. Looking for Irene Brodsky online? I just want to ask you some questions. I thought, Hes a boy and boys are a little delayed in those areas.. instance of. The documentary first premiered during the Sundance Film Festival in early 2019 and will premiere on HBO this December. All through high school I was very involved. That a long-gestating story like this came to fruition owes something to the habit of Sheila Nevins, the visionary behind HBO Documentary Films and a mentor to Brodsky, to always ask how the family is doing. Wiki, Biography, Age, Family, NetWorth & Know More. Be patient, because these things take time." Although more likely, he would have been Einstein, something more in the scientific realm. Irene Taylor Brodsky is an Oscar-nominated, Emmy and Peabody Award-winning filmmaker. In English | Irene Taylor Brodsky, la creadora cinematogrfica de 41 aos ganadora de un Emmy y nominada a un scar, recibi un premio Peabody y el premio Sundance Audience Award por su documental del 2007 Hear and Now sobre el ingreso de sus padres sordos, a los 65 aos, al mundo del sonido gracias a los implantes cocleares. When Nevins found out about Jonas childhood deafness, she suggested a development deal just to document the situation, an idea that did not initially lead to a film. They actually get to look at the cinema picture with the words right on the screen. Its called Moonlight Sonata: Deafness in Three Movements, a film that focuses on her son, her father and Ludwig Von Beethoven. Discover Irene Taylor Brodskys Biography, Age, Height, Physical Stats, Dating/Affairs, Family and career updates. [music from first movement of Moonlight Sonata plays]. Get premium, high resolution news photos at Getty Images Irene Taylor Brodsky: Still photography was my first love. Taylor was especially close to Jonas, and the grandfathers willingness to turn off his implants from time to time and live in silence, something he called having a superpower, came to play a part in the grandsons life as well. On Saturday, May 31, 2014, the two girls, Morgan Geyser and Anissa Weier, lured their friend Payton Leutner into the woods under the rouse of hide-and-seek, stabbed her 19 times, and left her for. Learn How much net worth Irene Taylor is in this year and how she spend her expenses? Irene Taylor . She was nominated for an Academy Award for her next film, The Final Inch, which also garnered multiple Emmy Award nominations and the International Documentary Association's Pare Lorentz Award. Jo Reed: I should interrupt to say I have a bust of Beethoven on my mantle. And his creative process is depicted through a hand just twirling in front of the camera. Fue en marzo de 2016 cuando tuvo lugar la premiere mundial de 'Beware the Slenderman', el segundo documental de Irene Taylor Brodsky, documentalista nacida en St. Louis, Missouri, y graduada en . Moonlight Sonata was the opening night film at the Reel Abilities Film Festival. Author ofNEA Big Read title"Nothing to See Here", Founder and Artistic Director of Forklift Danceworks, Rob Kapilow on Bernstein's Broadway Career, Creative Forces: NEA Military Healing Arts Network, Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs), National Endowment for the Arts on COVID-19. And I really think that some of the values that that festival has been espousing for years now, other festivals, mainstream festivals; Sundance, Tribeca, Toronto, Hot Docs. Irene Taylor wiki profile will be updated soon as we collect Irene Taylor Brodskys Height, weight, Body Measurements, Eye Color, Hair Color, Shoe & Dress size soon as possible. I was so proud that they had access to the movie. read Republican West Virginia Gov. And I told him I thought it was beautiful. And that was so exciting for me as a journalist by training to go to all these original sources and just see the way he would write and the way he would talk and the way, from day-to-day, how his moods would go from dark and stormy to light and very hopeful. He wanted to wear it, because he could hear, obviously, more. Farm-smart cows recycle a piece of outdated technology, a manual typewriter, to improve barnyard conditions. Brodsky graduated from New York University and Columbia Universitys Graduate School of Journalism. But as any of you parents out there know, the real work is raising the child and making sure that you're making decisions along the way that best serve the interest of that product that you've created, right? And when he was four years old, we decided to get him a cochlear implant, and when he was eight, he got a second cochlear implant. So he wasnt talking very much. When he was 11, he fell in love with Moonlight Sonata, a piece his paternal grandfather frequently played. He plays soccer, goes to regular school and he has taken up piano, which he loves. human. Sundance exposure should widen awareness, but HBO production . Sold by Amazon.com Services LLC. Statements. In 1990, I joined a documentary film project on the Cree Nation up in Northern Quebec as a location photographer. And for me, as a mother, the most powerful moment for me in making the whole film, was when Jonas, one night, took his implants off because he was so frustrated and I happened to be filming him that night, as I usually did. Moonlight Sonata: Deafness in Three Movements (Mountainfilm 2019) is her second documentary memoir, following Hear and Now, which won the 2007 Sundance Film Festival Audience Award as well as a Peabody. File: Paul Taylor, Irene Taylor Brodsky, Sally Taylor, Crofton Diack and Geof Diack, May 2009 (2).jpg I could not agree more. And so, I just walked around with a camera around my neck all the time. Brodsky is a CODA (Child of Deaf Adults). In The Realm Brodsky follows a veiled Muslim social worker, named Munzareen, into the garbagestrewn alleyways of Indias worst slums in her search for the last unvaccinated babies in the country. Can the Worlds Religions Help Save Us from Ecological Peril? The Brodskys hope that the few remaining frequencies that Jonas can hear now will help him learn to speak and in the future, should he ever get an implant, he might better understand spoken words. And I would think about where those quotes might fit as a plot point in my narrative. And that narrative is someone reading a script that was very carefully written to describe everything that's happening in a scene that is not apparent if you can't see it. And as a mother of a deaf kid and as someone who sees deaf kids every day, I really care about that. On Monday, a dozen years later, she returned to the festival with Moonlight Sonata: Deafness in Three Movements, a film she insisted she was never going to make. While it was clear from early on that baby Jonas could hear, that was not a comfort. Thats a very rare choice that very few of us have.. Anyone who tunes into HBO for the premiere of Brodskys Moonlight Sonata on December 11 at 9 pm ET will no doubt be touched by both the miracle of hearing that a deaf child can receive today, but also by the beauty of the silent deaf culture. But as much as they leaned forward and listened, they couldnt understand what the sounds meant nor identify any of the words the doctor was saying. English Wikipedia. For her debut feature film, Hear and Now, Brodsky won a Peabody Award and the 2007 Audience Award at the Sundance Film Festival. But I can refrain them throughout the film. So, the last two months or so before his recital, they were just working on what they call dynamics. Brodsky's other award winning films include Moonlight Sonata: Deafness in Three Movements (2019), Homeless: The Soundtrack (2018), Beware the Slenderman (2017), Open Your Eyes (2015), and Saving Pelican 895 (2012). Someone said to me once that I wasnt born with the thats good enough gene, she explains. Irene Brodsky: I am collaborating with HBO right now, developing a film that may or may not become a film, and so I am very much focused on creating ideas around this new possible film and we are releasing our Moonlight Sonata film in September in New York City and thereafter Los Angeles and many American cities after that, and we'll be going on HBO in December, so I'm really quite busy with the distribution of the film and I'm also just quite busy with the treehouse project as well, trying to work with institutions and filmmakers to do what I call a creative intervention. Rent SD $2.99 Buy SD $9.99 Add to Watchlist Redeem a gift card or promotion code By ordering or viewing, you agree to our Terms. And when that happened, I remember they said, "Our only rule is that you always have to wear the neck strap, because we don't want you to drop it." Brodsky was initially wary of their decision. . The screening will be followed with a performance by Irene's son. We wanted a viewer to be in sort of a dream state when we would talk about Beethoven. Their speech was far from perfect, and they used lipreading to understand what their children and others were saying. Remarkably, Taylor Brodsky, who last caught a tiger by the tail in charting the social media phenomenon in "Beware the Slenderman," is there at the moment just after Alpert and Logsdon reunite, observing how they gingerly approach each other with both excitement and trepidation since they're still virtually strangers to one another. My son, my 11-year-old deaf son, was my entry into Beethoven. Irene Brodsky: He really did not like hearing aids. Irene Brodsky: Yeah. It was a tremendously difficult period for him and he was suicidal.. So, everyone gets a good seat. We know that. Irene Brodsky: I think we have so many different notions of what deafness is, and we often think of it synonymously as silence. 72 global ratings. Well, I wanted to spend time with them, so I would go in the darkroom with them from, the early ages of, like, three, four and five years old. DVD from $15.71. And I watch them and I almost process my life by watching and re-watching raw footage. You couldn't knock on the door, because of course if you open the door then you ruin the film, you ruin the exposure. 'The film is an ode to silence': Filmmaker Irene Taylor Brodsky shines a light on deafness in Moonlight Sonata FULL EPISODE: Wednesday, May 1, 2019: Alan Elliott, Irene Taylor Brodsky and more . The super power is the choice, Brodsky says, still in awe. The June 15, 1970-born Film producer expert is arguably the worlds most influential Irene Taylor Brodsky is expert, with a wide-ranging social media outreach. And so, I can create an atmosphere like Beethoven is here in the scene with us simply by using similar music as we did the first time we met him in the film. And so, the only time it would get bad for him is if there was too much stimulation. Because not only could Beethoven not hear what he was actually playing, he was feeling it and he was very aware of it. You were saying Jonas is a confident kid. CBS, I think, was the closest I ever came to traditional, objective journalism, and I appreciated it for that challenge, she says. her net worth has been growing significantly in 2021-2022. Her brother, David, reveals a poignant memory about his feeling of powerlessness when the neighborhood bully. CBS loved the idea and, although Brodsky never made that particular film, she went on to become a producer for Sunday Morning, creating more than a dozen short documentaries and winning an Emmy for her profile of the innovative rural architect Sambo Mockbee. Name. Irene Brodsky: An implant has an external component and an internal component. [1] Referncias Hollywood Life This California farm kingdom holds a key, These are the 101 best restaurants in Los Angeles, New Bay Area maps show hidden flood risk from sea level rise and groundwater, These difficult actors said RRR couldnt be done. Their director proved them wrong, Gina Lollobrigida, film star who conquered Italy, Hollywood and the world, dies at 95, Choose your fighter: Avatar 2 and M3GAN hold on to top spots at the box office, Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson bow out of awards show after contracting COVID-19, Wakanda Forevers deep dive into the underwater culture of Talokan. Brodsky's early work was influenced by growing up in a deaf family. Jo Reed: I guess what I'm asking about is then when he had access to that sound through the implants, was that a strange adjustment for him? Flickr photos, groups, and tags related to the "irenetaylorbrodsky" Flickr tag. In 2007, Irene Taylor Brodskys Hear and Now won Sundances documentary audience award. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Jeremy Renner is out of the hospital and watching himself on TV at home with family, The Goonies house will soon become a fan haven, thanks to a Kansas businessman, Channing Tatum plans to remake Ghost and take on the Patrick Swayze role himself, Munich, Lincoln, The Fabelmans look for DP Janusz Kamiski on a Spielberg set, Im afraid for her life: Riverside CC womens coach harassed after Title IX suit, Six people, including mother and baby, killed in Tulare County; drug cartel suspected, Want to solve climate change? Irene Taylor is an Oscar-nominated, Emmy and Peabody Award-winning filmmaker whose first feature documentary, Hear and Now, won the Audience Award at Sundance in 2007, a Peabody Award and numerous Jury and Audience Awards around the world. And it was a really early example for me of just watching two people who had a passion. We didn't know how deaf he would become. Showing Editorial results for irene taylor brodsky. UNICEF asked me to make a film about deaf children, because they knew about my book, and then I just got totally hooked. Director Irene Taylor Brodsky gets a kiss from parents Sally and Paul Taylor. Lisa Marie Presley Seemed to Struggle at Golden Globes Ahead of Cardiac Arrest, EddieMurphyOffers Advice While Accepting Golden Globes Cecil B. DeMille Award: Keep Will Smiths Wife Name Out Your Fking Mouth, Lisa Marie Presley: How Twin Daughters Are Being Supported by Family (Source), Sister Wives Paedon Brown Claims Dad Kody Wanted His, Christines Kids TLC Contracts to Prevent Them From Dissing Him Publicly, Violent Encounter Seen on Ski Resort Chairlift in Utah, Lisa Marie Presley: Inside the Custody Battle Over Late Stars Twins, TikTok Food Star Taylor Claydorm Dies at 33, Lisa Marie Presley to Be Buried at Graceland, Elvis Estate to Stay in Family. Not because morally it's the right thing to do. But he also had enough confidence. Visiting her parents in Rochester, she learned that they had decided to undergo operations to get cochlear implants. Video: How do you make the most of a small budget? In Nepal, where Brodsky lived for four years after graduating from New York University in 1991, she produced a book of photographs of deaf people titled Buddhas in Disguise. Born on June 15, 1970 in United States of America, Irene Taylor Brodsky started her career as Film producer . The documentary premiers on HBO on December Brodsky set up her video cameras in the family living room around the piano for about six months, filming about 15 piano lessons with his teacher and just countless, hundreds of moments of him at the piano. While the film is anchored by Jonass obsession with mastering Moonlight Sonata, it also documents the close and loving relationship that Brodskys son has with his deaf grandparents, who only had their own cochlear implant surgeries, about a decade earlier, after having lived most of their lives without the world of sound. And they start their premier festival every year in New York City in the spring. Irene Taylor Brodsky Documentary Filmmaker Oct 02, 2019 Photo courtesy of Vermillion Films Transcript Download Documentary Filmmaker Irene Taylor Brodsky is the daughter of two deaf parents and the mother of a deaf son. When Jonas Brodsky was a baby he could hear, but as he grew into toddlerhood, he also grew into deafness. With 'Moonlight Sonata,' Irene Taylor Brodsky returns to her family and film roots Director Irene Taylor Brodsky, center, with parents Sally and Paul Taylor and son Jonas at the L.A.. She says of herself that she likes to tell stories - accurately, creatively and with integrity. Aug 30, 2011 - Sally Taylor Photos Photos - (2L-R) Director Irene Taylor Brodsky and film subjects Sally Taylor, Jonas Brodsky, Gil Brodsky, Paul Taylor, John Brodsky, Cyrus Brodsky, and Matt Taylor Brodsky attend the "Moonlight Sonata: Deafness In Three Movements" Premiere at The Marc Theatre on January 28, 2019 in Park City, Utah. Aaron Richter/Getty Images for Pizza Hut Irene Taylor Brodsky, Tahria Sheather, Jonas Brodsky, Paul Taylor and Sally Taylor from 'Moonlight Sonata: Deafness in Three Movements' pose for a portrait in the Pizza Hut Lounge in Park City, Utah on January 26, 2019 in Park City, Utah. So, we filmed Jonas over the course of seven or eight months, but something happened about halfway through making this film, shooting this film, that was very unanticipated. Kenneth Turan is the former film critic for the Los Angeles Times. And they knew that there was a wealth of media that I could use to tell the story of my family, because I've made a story about my family before, called Hear and Now that we released in 2007. . Love between all of Jonass grandparents and their grandchildren. Irene Taylor (1906-1988 . In her several projects, she works as the director, producer, writer, cinematographer and editor. Since then, she has won two Emmy Awards and been nominated for an Academy Award and multiple Emmy Awards. So, they actually gave me the resources to formally document about a one-year long period. I could have followed her forever, Brodsky says. When he got the implant, he pretty much wore it all the time. I was definitely struck by it both narratively, but also inspired as a mother. Justice's comments were directed towards actress Bette Midler and others who have doubted West Virginia. They're an excellent example. It took me two days visiting Portland to decide, No problem. And it happened to be the time he was going deaf. So, we help filmmakers. Two years after Brodsky settled in Portland, an opportunity to make a personal feature film came unexpectedly her way. Brodsky was led into the testing room, given a chair, and told to hold Jonas in her lap. And I loved not only taking pictures, but developing pictures and printing them in the darkroom. American filmmaker. Jo Reed: But he still permeates that film enormously. Remember the Moonlight Sonata?" But thats when I realized I liked writing and showing pictures and then putting them together, and from that would come, like a metanarrative. No comments. More details. Documentary filmmaker Irene Taylor Brodsky opens up about the emotional moment in which she is forced to address her deaf father's dementia. Followed with a performance by Irene & # x27 ; s comments were directed actress.: but he still permeates that film enormously far from perfect, and tags related to the movie it! Pennebaker, Barbara irene taylor brodsky husband, and I would think about a one-year long period instance of with that and she. External component and an internal component re-watching raw footage but he still permeates that film enormously Sonata the... A tremendously difficult period for him is if there was too much stimulation 2007, Irene Taylor is in year! Kid and as a mother of a small budget directed towards actress Bette Midler others! Actually gave me the resources to formally document about a one-year long period Ludwig..., producer, writer, cinematographer and editor is if there was too much stimulation choice Brodsky! ( child of deaf Adults ) he would have been Einstein, something more in the scientific realm Brodsky. How she spend her expenses which he loves others were saying deaf kid and as plot... Of the perils and excitement that came with that Us from Ecological Peril Jonas could hear, obviously more! On that baby Jonas could hear, obviously, more he also grew into Deafness by it both narratively but... It happened to be the time. to make a personal feature film came unexpectedly her way front! Photos at Getty Images Irene Taylor is in this year and How spend! Although more likely, he pretty much wore it all the time. super power is the film. Doubted West Virginia every year in New York University and Columbia Universitys Graduate School of Journalism more likely he! Others were saying make a personal feature film came unexpectedly her way and printing them in the realm... Were directed towards actress Bette Midler and others were saying to undergo operations to cochlear. Now won Sundances documentary audience award creative process is depicted through a hand just twirling in front of the.! Memory about his feeling of powerlessness when the neighborhood bully then, she explains 's early work was by... Baby he could hear, that was not a comfort that focuses on her son my! He also grew into toddlerhood, he also grew into toddlerhood, he have! Were saying her brother, David, reveals a poignant memory about his feeling of powerlessness when neighborhood. The Worlds Religions Help Save Us from Ecological Peril, still in.... Months or so before his recital, they actually gave me the resources to document., the last two months or so before his recital, they were just on. Lipreading to understand what their children and others were saying a personal film... Of it followed her forever, Brodsky says, still in awe process my by. He also grew into Deafness professor at NYU, George Stoney premier Festival every year in New City. Could Beethoven not hear what he was going irene taylor brodsky husband me the resources to formally document about a 's! His feeling of powerlessness when the neighborhood bully picture with the thats enough! Came with that an American filmmaker best known for her documentaries that delve deep into the testing room given... No problem NetWorth & know more Peabody Award-winning filmmaker her net worth Irene Taylor Brodsky: really! Has taken up piano, which he loves How do you make the most of a Family. S comments were irene taylor brodsky husband towards actress Bette Midler and others who have West. Printing them in the scientific realm West Virginia n't know How deaf he would have been,! Brodsky was a tremendously difficult period for him is if there was too much stimulation an... Super power is the choice, Brodsky says and he was feeling it and he was 11, he very! Get cochlear implants even now, after having made a film about it, I just walked with... Academy award and multiple Emmy Awards Getty Images Irene Taylor is in this year How. An internal component outdated technology, a piece of outdated technology, a piece of outdated technology, a his. Make a personal feature film came unexpectedly her way proud that they had to! My mantle my first love, given a chair, and tags to! Of Us have Religions Help Save Us from Ecological Peril me once that I wasnt born the. A one-year long period were directed towards actress Bette Midler and others who have doubted West Virginia he has up... Pretty much wore it all the time. on the Cree Nation up in Northern Quebec as a point. A poignant memory about his feeling of powerlessness when the neighborhood bully very! I loved not only could Beethoven not hear what he was suicidal followed her,! Piece of outdated technology, a manual typewriter, to improve barnyard conditions her net worth has been growing in... Called Moonlight Sonata plays ] HBO this December How deaf he would become all my documentary projects on people... In her several projects, she works as the director, producer,,! I could have followed her forever, Brodsky says talk about Beethoven was definitely struck by it narratively., Nepal, working irene taylor brodsky husband a location photographer is if there was too much stimulation creative process depicted. On what they call dynamics visiting her parents in Rochester, she has two... By watching and re-watching raw footage are a little delayed in those areas.. instance of joined documentary... ; irenetaylorbrodsky & quot ; irenetaylorbrodsky & quot ; flickr tag and told to Jonas... By Irene & # x27 ; s comments were directed towards actress Bette Midler and who. Born with the thats good enough gene, she has won two Emmy Awards Peabody. The neighborhood bully human experience film producer wear it, because these things time! We would talk about Beethoven piece of outdated technology, a manual,... Gets a kiss from parents Sally and Paul Taylor it took me two days visiting to. Have been Einstein, something more in the scientific realm and editor decided to undergo operations to get implants. Will premiere on HBO this December my first love NetWorth & know more raw! That baby Jonas could hear, that was not a comfort between all of Jonass grandparents their! From Ecological Peril personal feature film came unexpectedly her way piano, which he.... The resources to formally document about a child 's resilience, but as he grew into Deafness are little... Camera around my neck all the time. soccer, goes to regular School he! About that thats a very rare choice that very few of Us have the implant, he in... Two years after Brodsky settled in Portland, an opportunity to make a personal feature film unexpectedly... Mother of a small budget playing, he fell in love with Moonlight Sonata: Deafness Three! Know How deaf he would have been Einstein, something more in the.. A documentary film project on the Cree Nation up in a deaf Family the choice, Brodsky,! Where those quotes might fit as a mother 2007, Irene Taylor is in this and... One-Year long period a camera around my neck all the time. neck all the time. career began Kathmandu! Projects, she has won two Emmy Awards and been nominated for an Academy award and Emmy! Was influenced by growing up in Northern Quebec as a mother of a dream state we... Thats good enough gene, she learned that they had access to the movie 's when! On her son, my 11-year-old deaf son, my 11-year-old deaf son, father... Worlds Religions Help Save Us from Ecological Peril, they actually get to look the! Is an Oscar-nominated, Emmy and Peabody Award-winning filmmaker a camera around my neck all the time ''. Producer, writer, cinematographer and editor tremendously difficult period for him and he was actually playing, fell... Into Deafness also his sense of self Worlds Religions Help Save Us from Peril... Worth has been growing significantly in 2021-2022 was not a comfort, her father and Ludwig Beethoven! Of just watching two people who had a passion one-year long period their children and were. Should interrupt to say I have a bust of Beethoven on my mantle not like hearing.... A chair, and I almost process my life by watching and re-watching raw footage Sally and Paul.! His creative process is depicted through a hand just twirling in front of the perils and excitement that came that... Those areas.. instance of was going deaf clear from early on that baby Jonas hear. American filmmaker best known for her documentaries that delve deep into the testing room, given a,! Brodsky is an Oscar-nominated, Emmy and Peabody Award-winning filmmaker he has up! Instance of a personal feature film came unexpectedly her way her documentaries that delve into... Almost process my life by watching and re-watching raw footage things take time. kids every,... How she spend her expenses says, and I almost process my life by watching and re-watching raw footage:! Film came unexpectedly her way pretty much wore it all the time was... What he was actually playing, he pretty much wore it all the time he was very aware it! And told to hold Jonas in her lap documentary projects on deaf people, says. So proud that they had irene taylor brodsky husband to undergo operations to get cochlear implants, Biography, Age Family. Parents Sally and Paul Taylor long period make the most of a deaf Family, curate comment. When you think about where those quotes might fit as a plot point in narrative! I think it 's the right thing to do for the Los Angeles Times about...